Skip to main content
Holderness, NH

28 Potato Island

$1,750,000

MLS# 5093853 · Single Family Residence

54 days on market
The Listing

A 2-bedroom home in Holderness on Squam Lake.

2
Bedrooms
2
Baths
1,538
Sq Ft
0.4
Acres
Waterfront· Squam Lake· Deep Water Access, Directly Adjoining, Dock Access

Description

Early visitors to Squam Lake came seeking an escape from industrial life and to immerse themselves in a quiet wilderness. Formerly known as “Elizabeth Island”, Potato Island, as it’s known today, has stood the test of time. Only a short boat ride from restaurants and provisions of downtown Holderness, it’s time to immerse yourself in your own private island retreat. Tie your vessel to the U-shaped dock and unload and unwind for the weekend. The Island welcomes you with blueberry bushes, sunrises & sunsets, and a full array of wildlife. A seasonal cottage originally built in the 1930’s offers comfortable living with an updated kitchen from the 1990’s and a large sleeping loft on the 2nd floor. Evenings are spent on the large front porch or in front of the campfire as you listen to the Loons before bed. A generous outbuilding houses everything you may need for island life, including a generator, fuel, and various watercraft. Enjoy the outdoor shower as you begin your day on the Lake. Now is your time to enjoy Squam Lake the way it was meant to be enjoyed.

Features

Interior

Furnished
Kitchen/Dining
Natural Light
Natural Woodwork

Exterior

Boat Mooring
Boat Slip
Natural Shade
Outbuilding
Porch
Covered Porch
Private Dock
Shed

Heating

Space Heater

Cooling

None

Request Information

Interested in this property? One of our agents will follow up with you directly.

Financial

Annual Taxes
$20,023

Location

Listing History

This property was listed at $1,999,000 on Jun 10, 2026. The price was reduced by $249,000 (12.5%) to $1,750,000 on Invalid Date. It has been on the market for 54 days.

Residential · NH-Grafton County · Listed Jun 10, 2026

About Holderness, NH

Holderness is famous as the home of Squam Lake, the filming location for "On Golden Pond." Plymouth State University is nearby, and the town offers a mix of academic community, nature tourism, and some of the most pristine lakefront in New England.

Squam Lakes Natural Science Center
"On Golden Pond" filming location
Squam Lake, pristine & secluded
Near Plymouth State University
Rattlesnake Mountain hike (easy, great views)
White Oak Pond
County: Grafton
Population: ~2,100
Schools: Pemi-Baker Regional (SAU 48)

Distances are approximate. Click any destination for driving directions. NH has no state income tax or sales tax.

Other Waterfront Listings on Squam Lake

AddressPrice
26 Myrtle Drive$1,850,000
38 Lake Shore Drive$1,750,000
27 First Point Road$1,650,000
9 Starboard Lane$1,590,000
37 Tamwood Road$1,395,000

Active listings within 25% of this price. Browse all for-sale.

Recently Sold in Holderness

AddressSold PriceSold
1047 New Hampshire Route 175$400,000Jul 31, 2026
16 Hemlock Way$1,600,000Jul 31, 2026
388 Perch Pond Road$555,000Jul 29, 2026
137 Sargent Road$845,000Jul 24, 2026
11 Sebec Road$930,020Jul 1, 2026
73 Bennett Cove Lane$5,150,000Jul 1, 2026

Closed sales in the past 12 months. Data from PrimeMLS.

$1,750,000

Active Listing

Bedrooms2
Bathrooms2
Sq Ft1,538
$/Sq Ft$1138
Listing courtesy of Badger Peabody & Smith Realty/Holderness · Jerrod Mitchell · 603-968-7615 · Cell: 603-548-1554
PrimeMLS

IDX display courtesy of Yankee Pedlar Realtors, Wolfeboro NH.

PrimeMLS Listing Information displayed herein is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by PrimeMLS. This display of listings may or may not be the entire Compilation from the PrimeMLS database, and PrimeMLS does not guarantee the accuracy of such information. © PrimeMLS, Inc.

Listing brokers may report inaccurate data to michelle@yankeepedlarrealtors.com or call (603) 569-1000.