Skip to main content
Moultonborough, NH

170 Black Cat Island Road

$3,900,000Last sold Oct 16, 2026Listed at $4,250,000Sold in 68 days

MLS# 5104137 · Single Family Residence

Back to results
The Listing

A 2-bedroom home in Moultonborough on Lake Winnipesaukee.

2
Bedrooms
4
Baths
3,193
Sq Ft
0.4
Acres
Waterfront· Lake Winnipesaukee· Directly Adjoining, Dock Access

Description

Imagine being on the pristine shores of Lake Winnipesaukee in the highly sought-after low-tax town of Moultonborough, where timeless lakefront living meets exceptional craftsmanship. Situated on one of 3 bridged islands, completely renovated and thoughtfully expanded in 2014, this remarkable waterfront was redesigned to maximize natural light and capture breathtaking lake views from nearly every room. There have been many recent upgrades also, roof, furnace and hot water in 2026, some newer appliances, new built in grill, chimney and cap, and more. The reimagined floor plan offers an effortless blend of elegance and comfort, highlighted by an expanded primary suite featuring a spacious walk-in closet and luxurious en-suite bath. Every bathroom has been beautifully renovated with premium finishes, while new insulation, updated electrical wiring, Mitsubishi split-system air conditioning, and radiant heated floors in the welcoming front entry provide modern comfort and efficiency throughout. Designed for unforgettable lakeside living, the outdoor spaces are equally impressive. An expansive low maintenance deck with contemporary cable railings creates the perfect vantage point to take in the water and gorgeous mountain views,while the amazing screened porch complete with panoramic screens and a stunning stone fireplace extends the living space through every season. A bluestone patio with a built-in fire pit, outdoor grilling station, and professionally designed landscaping and fencing provide an exceptional setting for entertaining family and friends along the shores of New Hampshire's most iconic lake. From the custom stone and wood front entry to the thoughtfully added third-floor powder room, every detail reflects quality and intentional design. This is a rare opportunity to own a beautifully private waterfront home offering luxury, and an unparalleled lifestyle on Lake Winnipesaukee in one of the Lakes Region's most desirable communities.

Features

Interior

Bar
Gas Fireplace
3+ Fireplaces
Furnished
Kitchen/Dining
Kitchen/Living
Primary BR w/ BA
Natural Light
Natural Woodwork
Indoor Storage
Walk-In Closet(s)
Wet Bar
Basement Laundry

Exterior

Boat Slip
Dock
Deck
Natural Shade
Outbuilding
Patio
Screened Porch
Private Dock
Storage
Built in Gas Grill

Heating

Propane
Hot Water
Gas Stove
Mini Split
Gas Fireplace

Cooling

Mini Split

Parking

Detached
Driveway
Garage

Financial

Annual Taxes
$14,245

Location

Listing History

This property was listed on Aug 9, 2026. It went under contract but came back on the market on Invalid Date. It sold on Oct 16, 2026 for $3,900,000, $350,000 (8.2%) below the original asking price.

Residential · NH-Carroll County · Listed Aug 9, 2026 · Sold Oct 16, 2026

About Moultonborough, NH

Moultonborough wraps around the northern and western shores of Lake Winnipesaukee and includes popular Long Island. Known for its low tax rate, excellent schools, and the iconic Castle in the Clouds, it's a top choice for both vacation homeowners and year-round families.

✓Lowest tax rate in the Lakes Region
✓Castle in the Clouds historic estate
✓Red Hill summit with panoramic lake views
✓Long Island, largest lake island community
✓Lees Mills boat launch
✓Old Country Store (est. 1781)
County: Carroll
Population: ~4,800
Schools: Inter-Lakes (SAU 2)

Distances are approximate. Click any destination for driving directions. NH has no state income tax or sales tax.

Other Waterfront Listings on Lake Winnipesaukee

AddressPrice
35 Rocky Shore Road$4,990,000
74 Keewaydin Road$4,900,000
28 Veasey Shore Road$4,795,000
6 Governor Wentworth Highway$4,395,000
456 Governor Wentworth Highway$4,195,000
5 Loon Cove Road$3,999,000

Active listings within 25% of this price. Browse all for-sale.

Recently Sold in Moultonborough

AddressSold PriceSold
37 Tamwood Road$1,120,000Oct 15, 2026
145 Hanson Drive$3,805,000Oct 15, 2026
456 Sheridan Road$581,500Oct 14, 2026
294 Paradise Drive$1,200,000Oct 14, 2026
100 Olympia Street$675,000Oct 13, 2026
21 Shangri La Drive$750,000Oct 9, 2026

Closed sales in the past 12 months. Data from PrimeMLS.

$3,900,000

Sold Oct 16, 2026

Bedrooms2
Bathrooms4
Sq Ft3,193
$/Sq Ft$1221
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty Center Harbor NH · Ellen Mulligan · 603-253-4345 · Cell: 603-387-0369 · Selling office: Maxfield Real Estate/Center Harbor
PrimeMLS

IDX display courtesy of Yankee Pedlar Realtors, Wolfeboro NH.

PrimeMLS Listing Information displayed herein is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by PrimeMLS. This display of listings may or may not be the entire Compilation from the PrimeMLS database, and PrimeMLS does not guarantee the accuracy of such information. © PrimeMLS, Inc.

Listing brokers may report inaccurate data to michelle@yankeepedlarrealtors.com or call (603) 569-1000.